| 31 | 1942 | Teresa Wright - Mrs. Miniver - "Carol Beldon Miniver" |
| 32 | 1942 | Gladys Cooper - Now, Voyager - "Mrs. Henry Windle Vale" |
| 33 | 1942 | Agnes Moorehead - The Magnificent Ambersons - "Fanny Minafer" |
| 34 | 1942 | Susan Peters - Random Harvest - "Kitty Chilcet" |
| 35 | 1942 | May Whitty - Mrs. Miniver - "Lady Beldon" |
| 36 | 1943 | Katina Paxinou - For Whom the Bell Tolls - "Pilar" |
| 37 | 1943 | Gladys Cooper - The Song of Bernadette - Sister Marie Therese Vauzous |
| 38 | 1943 | Paulette Goddard - So Proudly We Hail! - "Lt. Joan O'Doul" |
| 39 | 1943 | Anne Revere - The Song of Bernadette - Louise Soubirous |
| 40 | 1943 | Lucile Watson - Watch on the Rhine - "Fanny Farrelly" |
| 41 | 1944 | Ethel Barrymore - None but the Lonely Heart - "Ma Mott" |
| 42 | 1944 | Jennifer Jones - Since You Went Away - "Jane Deborah Hilton" |
| 43 | 1944 | Angela Lansbury - Gaslight - "Nancy Oliver" |
| 44 | 1944 | Aline MacMahon - Dragon Seed - "Ling Tan's Wife" |
| 45 | 1944 | Agnes Moorehead - Mrs. Parkington - "Aspasia Conti" |
| 46 | 1945 | Anne Revere - National Velvet - "Mrs. Araminty Brown" |
| 47 | 1945 | Eve Arden - Mildred Pierce - "Ida Corwin" |
| 48 | 1945 | Ann Blyth - Mildred Pierce - "Veda Pierce Forrester" |
| 49 | 1945 | Angela Lansbury - The Picture of Dorian Gray - "Sibyl Vane" |
| 50 | 1945 | Joan Lorring - The Corn is Green - "Bessie Watty" |
| 51 | 1946 | Anne Baxter - The Razor's Edge - "Sopie Nelson Macdonald" |
| 52 | 1946 | Ethel Barrymore - The Spiral Staircase - "Mrs. Warren" |
| 53 | 1946 | Lillian Gish - Duel in the Sun - "Laura Belle McCanles" |
| 54 | 1946 | Flora Robson - Saratoga Trunk - "Angelique Buiton" |
| 55 | 1946 | Gale Sondergaard - Anna and the King of Siam - "Lady Thiang" |
| 56 | 1947 | Celeste Holm - Centilmenlik Anlaşması - "Anne Dettrey" |
| 57 | 1947 | Ethel Barrymore - The Paradine Case - "Lady Sophie Horfield" |
| 58 | 1947 | Gloria Grahame - Crossfire - "Ginny Tremaine" |
| 59 | 1947 | Marjorie Main - The Egg and I - "Ma Kettle" |
| 60 | 1947 | Anne Revere - Gentleman's Agreement - "Mrs. Revere" |