| 121 | 1952 | The Man in the White Suit - John Dighton, Roger MacDougall, Alexander Mackendrick |
| 122 | 1952 | The Quiet Man - Frank S. Nugent, |
| 123 | 1953 | İnsanlar Yaşadıkça (From Here to Eternity) - Daniel Taradash |
| 124 | 1953 | The Cruel Sea - Eric Ambler |
| 125 | 1953 | Lilli - Helen Deutsch |
| 126 | 1953 | Roma Tatili (Roman Holiday) - Ian McLellan Hunter, John Dighton |
| 127 | 1953 | Shane - A.B. Guthrie Jr. |
| 128 | 1954 | Taşralı Kız - George Seaton |
| 129 | 1954 | Gemide İsyan (The Caine Mutiny) - Stanley Roberts |
| 130 | 1954 | Arka Pencere (Rear Window) - John Michael Hayes |
| 131 | 1954 | Sabrina - Billy Wilder, Samuel A. Taylor, Ernest Lehman |
| 132 | 1954 | Yedi Kardeşe Yedi Gelin (Seven Brides for Seven Brothers) - Albert Hackett, Frances Gooderich, Dorothy Kingsley |
| 133 | 1955 | Marty - Paddy Chayefsky |
| 134 | 1955 | Zafer Madalyası (Bad Day at Black Rock) - Millard Kaufman |
| 135 | 1955 | Karatahta Ormanı (Blackboard Jungle) - Richard Brooks |
| 136 | 1955 | Cennetin Doğusu (East of Eden) - Paul Osborn |
| 137 | 1955 | Sev ya da Terket (Love Me or Leave Me) - Daniel Fuchs, Isobel Lennart |
| 138 | 1956 | 1956 yılından itibaren ödül kategorisi, Senaryo-Uyarlama olarak, yeniden isimlendirildi. |
| 139 | 1956 | 80 Günde Devr-i Alem (Around the World in Eighty Days) - John Farrow, S. J. Perelman, James Poe |
| 140 | 1956 | Taş Bebek (Baby Doll) - Tennessee Williams |
| 141 | 1956 | Kan Dökmeyeceksin (Friendly Persuasion) - Michael Wilson |
| 142 | 1956 | Giant - Fred Guiol, Ivan Moffat |
| 143 | 1956 | Yaşama Tutkusu (Lust for Life) - Norman Corwin |
| 144 | 1956 | For 1957 the category was renamed Screenplay Based on Material from Another Medium: |
| 145 | 1957 | Kwai Köprüsü (The Bridge on the River Kwai) - Carl Foreman, Michael Wilson |
| 146 | 1957 | Heaven Knows, Mr. Allison - John Huston, John Lee Mahin |
| 147 | 1957 | Peyton Aşıkları (Peyton Place) - John Michael Hayes |
| 148 | 1957 | Sayonara - Paul Osborn |
| 149 | 1957 | 12 Kızgın Adam (12 Angry Men) - Reginald Rose |
| 150 | 1958 | Gigi - Alan Jay Lerner |