| 1 | 1936 | Gale Sondergaard - Anthony Adverse - "Faith Paleologus" |
| 2 | 1936 | Beulah Bondi - The Gorgeous Hussy - Rachel Jackson |
| 3 | 1936 | Alice Brady - My Man Godfrey - "Angelica Bullock" |
| 4 | 1936 | Bonita Granville - These Three - "Mary Tilford" |
| 5 | 1936 | Maria Ouspenskaya - Dodsworth - "Baroness Von Obersdorf" |
| 6 | 1937 | Alice Brady - In Old Chicago - "Mrs. Molly O'Leary" |
| 7 | 1937 | Andrea Leeds - Stage Door - "Kaye Hamilton" |
| 8 | 1937 | Anne Shirley - Stella Dallas - "Laurel 'Lollie' Dallas" |
| 9 | 1937 | Claire Trevor - Dead End - "Franice" |
| 10 | 1937 | May Whitty - Night Must Fall - "Mrs. Bramson" |
| 11 | 1938 | Fay Bainter - Jezebel - "Aunt Belle Massey" |
| 12 | 1938 | Beulah Bondi - Of Human Hearts - "Mary Wilkins" |
| 13 | 1938 | Billie Burke - Merrily We Live - "Mrs. Emily Kilbourne" |
| 14 | 1938 | Spring Byington - You Can't Take It with You - "Penny Sycamore" |
| 15 | 1938 | Miliza Korjus - The Great Waltz - "Carla Donner" |
| 16 | 1939 | Hattie McDaniel - Gone with the Wind - "Mammy" |
| 17 | 1939 | Olivia de Havilland - Gone with the Wind - "Melanie Hamilton Wilkes" |
| 18 | 1939 | Geraldine Fitzgerald - Wuthering Heights as "Isabella Linton" |
| 19 | 1939 | Edna May Oliver - Drums Along the Mohawk - "Mrs. McKlennar" |
| 20 | 1939 | Maria Ouspenskaya - Love Affair - "Grandmother Janou" |
| 21 | 1940 | Jane Darwell - The Grapes of Wrath - "Ma Joad" |
| 22 | 1940 | Judith Anderson - Rebecca - "Mrs. Danvers" |
| 23 | 1940 | Ruth Hussey - The Philadelphia Story - "Elizabeth Imbrie" |
| 24 | 1940 | Barbara O'Neil - All This and Heaven Too - "Duchesse de Pr-lin" |
| 25 | 1940 | Marjorie Rambeau - Primrose Path - "Mamie Adams" |
| 26 | 1941 | Mary Astor - The Great Lie - "Sandra Kovak" |
| 27 | 1941 | Sara Allgood - How Green W- My Valley - "Beth Morgan" |
| 28 | 1941 | Patricia Collinge - The Little Foxes - "Birdie Hubbard" |
| 29 | 1941 | Teresa Wright - The Little Foxes - "Alexandra Giddens" |
| 30 | 1941 | Margaret Wycherly - Sergeant York - "Mother York" |