| 151 | 1959 | Paul Muni - The Last Angry Man - "Dr. Sam Abelman" |
| 152 | 1959 | James Stewart - Anatomy of a Murder - "Paul Biegler" |
| 153 | 1960 | Burt Lancaster - Elmer Gantry - "Elmer Gantry" |
| 154 | 1960 | Trevor Howard - Sons and Lovers - "Walter Morel" |
| 155 | 1960 | Jack Lemmon - Garsoniyer - "C.C. Baxter" |
| 156 | 1960 | Laurence Olivier - The Entertainer - "Archie Rice" |
| 157 | 1960 | Spencer Tracy - Inherit the Wind - "Henry Drummond" |
| 158 | 1961 | Maximilian Schell - Judgment at Nuremberg - "Hans Rolfe" |
| 159 | 1961 | Charles Boyer - Fanny - "Fanny" |
| 160 | 1961 | Paul Newman - The Hustler - "F-t Eddie Felson" |
| 161 | 1961 | Spencer Tracy - Judgment at Nuremberg - "Chief Judge Dan Haywood" |
| 162 | 1961 | Stuart Whitman - The Mark - "Jim Fuller" |
| 163 | 1962 | Gregory Peck - Bülbülü Öldürmek - "Atticus Finch" |
| 164 | 1962 | Burt Lancaster - Alkatraz Kuşçusu - Robert Stroud |
| 165 | 1962 | Jack Lemmon - Days of Wine and Roses - "Joe Clay" |
| 166 | 1962 | Marcello Mastroianni - İtalyan Usulü Boşanma - "Ferdinando Cefalú" |
| 167 | 1962 | Peter O'Toole - Arabistanlı Lawrence - T. E. Lawrence |
| 168 | 1963 | Sidney Poitier - Lilies of the Field - "Homer Smith" |
| 169 | 1963 | Albert Finney - Tom Jones - "Tom Jones" |
| 170 | 1963 | Richard Harris - This Sporting Life - "Frank Machin" |
| 171 | 1963 | Rex Harrison - Cleopatra - Julius Caesar |
| 172 | 1963 | Paul Newman - Hud - "Hud Bannon" |
| 173 | 1964 | Rex Harrison - My Fair Lady - "Henry Higgins" |
| 174 | 1964 | Richard Burton - Becket - Thomas Becket |
| 175 | 1964 | Peter O'Toole - Becket - Henry II of England |
| 176 | 1964 | Anthony Quinn - Zorba the Greek - "Alexis Zorba" |
| 177 | 1964 | Peter Sellers - Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb - "Group Captain Lionel Mendrake," "President Merkin Muffley," ve "Dr. Strangelove" |
| 178 | 1965 | Lee Marvin - Cat Ballou - "Kid Sheleen" ve "Tim Strawn" |
| 179 | 1965 | Richard Burton - The Spy Who Came in from the Cold - "Alec Leamas" |
| 180 | 1965 | Laurence Olivier - Othello - "Othello" |