| 301 | 1954 | The Glenn Miller Story - Joseph Gershenson, Henry Mancini |
| 302 | 1954 | A Star Is Born - Ray Heindorf |
| 303 | 1954 | There's No Business Like Show Business - Alfred Newman, Lionel Newman |
| 304 | 1955 | MUSIC (Score of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture): Love Is a Many-Splendored Thing - Alfred Newman |
| 305 | 1955 | Battle Cry - Max Steiner |
| 306 | 1955 | The Man with the Golden Arm - Elmer Bernstein |
| 307 | 1955 | Picnic - George Duning |
| 308 | 1955 | The Rose Tattoo - Alex North |
| 309 | 1955 | MUSIC (Scoring of a Musical Picture): Oklahoma! - Robert Russell Bennett, Jay Blackton, Adolph Deutsch |
| 310 | 1955 | Daddy Long Legs - Alfred Newman |
| 311 | 1955 | Guys and Dolls - Jay Blackton, Cyril J. Mockridge |
| 312 | 1955 | It's Always Fair Weather - Andre Previn |
| 313 | 1955 | Love Me or Leave Me - Percy Faith, George Stoll |
| 314 | 1956 | MUSIC (Score of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture): Around the World in Eighty Days - Victor Young (posthumous award) |
| 315 | 1956 | Anastasia - Alfred Newman |
| 316 | 1956 | Between Heaven and Hell - Hugo Friedhofer |
| 317 | 1956 | Giant - Dimitri Tiomkin |
| 318 | 1956 | The Rainmaker - Alex North |
| 319 | 1956 | MUSIC (Scoring of a Musical Picture): The King and I - Alfred Newman, Ken Darby |
| 320 | 1956 | The Best Things in Life Are Free - Lionel Newman |
| 321 | 1956 | The Eddy Duchin Story - Morris Stoloff, George Duning |
| 322 | 1956 | High Society - Johnny Green, Saul Chaplin |
| 323 | 1956 | Meet Me in Las Vegas - George Stoll, Johnny Green |
| 324 | 1957 | MUSIC (Score): The Bridge on the River Kwai - Malcolm Arnold |
| 325 | 1957 | An Affair to Remember - Hugo Friedhofer |
| 326 | 1957 | Boy on a Dolphin - Hugo Friedhofer |
| 327 | 1957 | Perri - Paul Smith |
| 328 | 1957 | Raintree County - Johnny Green |
| 329 | 1958 | MUSIC (Score of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture): The Old Man and the Sea - Dimitri Tiomkin |
| 330 | 1958 | The Big Country - Jerome Moross |