| 31 | 1942 | Van Heflin - Johnny Eager - "Jeff Hartnett" |
| 32 | 1942 | William Bendix - Wake Island - "Pvt. Aloysius K. 'Smacksie' Randall" |
| 33 | 1942 | Walter Huston - Yankee Doodle Dandy - Jere Cohan |
| 34 | 1942 | Frank Morgan - Tortilla Flat - "Pirate" |
| 35 | 1942 | Henry Travers - Mrs. Miniver - "Mr. Ballard" |
| 36 | 1943 | Charles Coburn - The More the Merrier - "Benjamin Dingle" |
| 37 | 1943 | Charles Bickford - The Song of Bernadette - Father Dominique Peyramale |
| 38 | 1943 | J. Carrol Naish - Sahara - "Giuseppe" |
| 39 | 1943 | Claude Rains - Casablanca - "Captain Renault" |
| 40 | 1943 | Akim Tamiroff - For Whom the Bell Tolls - "Pablo" |
| 41 | 1944 | Barry Fitzgerald - Yolumda Giderken - "Father Fitzgibbon" |
| 42 | 1944 | Hume Cronyn - The Seventh Cross - "Paul Roeder" |
| 43 | 1944 | Claude Rains - Mr. Skeffington - "Job Skeffington" |
| 44 | 1944 | Clifton Webb - Laura - "Waldo Lydecker" |
| 45 | 1944 | Monty Woolley - Since You Went Away - "Colonel William G. Smollett" |
| 46 | 1945 | James Dunn - A Tree Grows In Brooklyn - "Johnny Nolan aka The Brooklyn Thrush" |
| 47 | 1945 | Michael Chekhov - Spellbound - "Dr. Alexander 'Alex' Brulov" |
| 48 | 1945 | John Dall - The Corn Is Green - "Morgan Evans" |
| 49 | 1945 | Robert Mitchum - The Story of G.I. Joe - "Lt./Capt. Bill Walker" |
| 50 | 1945 | J. Carroll Naish - A Medal for Benny - "Charley Martin" |
| 51 | 1946 | Harold Russell - The Best Years of Our Lives - "Homer Parrish" |
| 52 | 1946 | Charles Coburn - The Green Years - "Alexander 'Dandy' Gow" |
| 53 | 1946 | William Demarest - The Jolson Story - "Steve Martin" |
| 54 | 1946 | Claude Rains - Notorious - "Alexander Sebastian" |
| 55 | 1946 | Clifton Webb - The Razor's Edge - "Elliott Templeton" |
| 56 | 1947 | Edmund Gwenn - Miracle on 34th Street - "Kris Kringle" |
| 57 | 1947 | Charles Bickford - The Farmer's Daughter - "Joseph Clancey" |
| 58 | 1947 | Thomas Gomez - Ride the Pink Horse - "Pancho" |
| 59 | 1947 | Robert Ryan - Crossfire - "Montgomery" |
| 60 | 1947 | Richard Widmark - Kiss of Death - "Tommy Udo" |