| 91 | 1954 | Edmond O'Brien - The Barefoot Contessa - "Oscar Muldoon" |
| 92 | 1954 | Lee J. Cobb - On the Waterfront - "Johnny Friendly" |
| 93 | 1954 | Karl Malden - On the Waterfront - "Father Barry" |
| 94 | 1954 | Rod Steiger - On the Waterfront - "Charley 'the Gent' Malloy" |
| 95 | 1954 | Tom Tully - The Caine Mutiny - "Commander DeVriess" |
| 96 | 1955 | Jack Lemmon - Mister Roberts - "Ens. Frank Thurlowe Pulver" |
| 97 | 1955 | Arthur Kennedy - Trial - "Barney Castle" |
| 98 | 1955 | Joe Mantell - Marty - "Angie" |
| 99 | 1955 | Sal Mineo - Rebel Without a Cause - "John 'Plato' Crawford" |
| 100 | 1955 | Arthur O'Connell - Picnic - "Howard Bevans" |
| 101 | 1956 | Anthony Quinn - Lust for Life - Paul Gauguin |
| 102 | 1956 | Don Murray - Bus Stop - "Beauregard 'Bo' Decker" |
| 103 | 1956 | Anthony Perkins - Friendly Persuasion - "Josh Birdwell" |
| 104 | 1956 | Mickey Rooney - The Bold and the Brave - "Dooley" |
| 105 | 1956 | Robert Stack - Written on the Wind - "Kyle Hadley" |
| 106 | 1957 | Red Buttons - Sayonara - "Airman Joe Kelly" |
| 107 | 1957 | Vittorio De Sica - A Farewell to Arms - "Major Alessandro Rinaldi" |
| 108 | 1957 | Sessue Hayakawa - The Bridge on the River Kwai - "Colonel Saito" |
| 109 | 1957 | Arthur Kennedy - Peyton Place - "Luc - Cross" |
| 110 | 1957 | Russ Tamblyn - Peyton Place - "Norman Page" |
| 111 | 1958 | Burl Ives - The Big Country - "Rufus Hannassey" |
| 112 | 1958 | Theodore Bikel - The Defiant Ones - "Sheriff Max Muller" |
| 113 | 1958 | Lee J. Cobb - The Brothers Karamazov - "Fyodor Karamazov" |
| 114 | 1958 | Arthur Kennedy - Some Came Running - "Frank Hirsh" |
| 115 | 1958 | Gig Young - Teacher's Pet - "Dr. Hugo Pine" |
| 116 | 1959 | Hugh Griffith - Ben-Hur - "Sheik Ilderim" |
| 117 | 1959 | Arthur O'Connell - Anatomy of a Murder - "Parnell Emmett McCarthy" |
| 118 | 1959 | George C. Scott - Anatomy of a Murder - " -st. State Atty. Gen. Claude Dancer" |
| 119 | 1959 | Robert Vaughn - The Young Philadelphians - "Chester A. 'Chet' Gwynn" |
| 120 | 1959 | Ed Wynn - The Diary of Anne Frank - Albert Dussell |