| 121 | 1960 | Peter Ustinov - Spartacus - Lentulus Batiatus |
| 122 | 1960 | Peter Falk - Murder, Inc. - "Abe 'Kid Twist' Reles" |
| 123 | 1960 | Jack Kruschen - The Apartment - "Dr. Dreyfuss" |
| 124 | 1960 | Sal Mineo - Exodus - "Dov Landau" |
| 125 | 1960 | Chill Wills - The Alamo - "Beekeeper" |
| 126 | 1961 | George Chakiris - West Side Story - "Bernardo" |
| 127 | 1961 | Montgomery Clift - Judgment at Nuremberg - "Rudolph Petersen" |
| 128 | 1961 | Peter Falk - Pocketful of Miracles - "Joy Boy" |
| 129 | 1961 | Jackie Gle -on - The Hustler - "Minnesota Fats" |
| 130 | 1961 | George C. Scott - The Hustler - "Bert Gordon" |
| 131 | 1962 | Ed Begley - Sweet Bird of Youth - "Tom 'Boss' Finley" |
| 132 | 1962 | Victor Buono - What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? - "Edwin Flagg" |
| 133 | 1962 | Telly Savalas - Birdman of Alcatraz - "Feto Gomez" |
| 134 | 1962 | Omar Sharif - Lawrence of Arabia - Sherif Ali ibn el Kharish |
| 135 | 1962 | Terence Stamp - Billy Budd - "Billy Budd" |
| 136 | 1963 | Melvyn Douglas - Hud - "Homer Bannon" |
| 137 | 1963 | Nick Adams - Twilight of Honor - "Ben Brown" |
| 138 | 1963 | Bobby Darin - Captain Newman, M.D. - "Corporal Jim Tompkins" |
| 139 | 1963 | Hugh Griffith - Tom Jones - "Squire Western" |
| 140 | 1963 | John Huston - The Cardinal - "Cardinal Glennon" |
| 141 | 1964 | Peter Ustinov - Topkapi "Arthur Simon Simpson" |
| 142 | 1964 | John Gielgud - Becket - Louis VII |
| 143 | 1964 | Stanley Holloway - My Fair Lady - "Alfred Doolittle" |
| 144 | 1964 | Edmond O'Brien - Seven Days in May - " Senator Raymond Clark" |
| 145 | 1964 | Lee Tracy - The Best Man - "Art Hockstader" |
| 146 | 1965 | Martin Balsam - A Thousand Clowns - "Arnold Burns" |
| 147 | 1965 | Ian Bannen - The Flight of the Phoenix - "'Ratbags' Crow" |
| 148 | 1965 | Tom Courtenay - Doctor Zhivago - "Pasha Antipov" |
| 149 | 1965 | Michael Dunn - Ship of Fools - "Carl Glocken" |
| 150 | 1965 | Frank Finlay - Othello - "Iago" |